Xi’s power grab in China is a big deal

Regularized and predictable change of leadership is perhaps the most important indicator of political development. It doesn’t matter if such changes occur through popular elections (as in electoral democracies), boardroom meetings (in party dictatorships), or through inheritance (as in monarchies). Predictability provides stability and allows for the cultivation of elite consensus over a system of rule. It also provides the background conditions necessary for the rule of law to emerge. A situation in which rules change with rulers is hostile to constitutionalism.

jinpingThis is precisely why life presidencies are sub-optimal. Long tenures eventually convince even the most democratic of leaders that they are above the law. They freeze specific groups of elites out of power. And remove incentives for those in power to be accountable and to innovate.

For a while China seemed to have turned this corner, having imposed term limits on its state presidents. But President Xi Jinping has thrown that consensus out the window with the announcement that he plans to scrap term limits and presumably stay on as president indefinitely. 

This is a big deal. Xi has revealed to us that he is no different than Yoweri Museveni.

Who would have guessed that in the 21st century we would be back to a situation in which the world’s biggest economy has life presidents, and occasionally goes through unpredictable transfers of power? Certainly, the coup risk in China is likely to go up under a life presidency. And the demonstration effect to other autocracies will be huge. Remember that even Vladimir Putin had to engage in questionable institutional jujitsu by allowing his wingman to be president in order not to flout the Russian constitution.

global_tenuremean.pngXi’s China is a reminder of that political development is not uni-directional. It is also a caution against trust that elites’ material interests are a bulwark against would-be personalist dictators. China’s economy is booming (albeit at a slower rate of growth), and continues to mint dollar billionaires. Yet the country’s political and economic elites appear helpless in the face of a single man who is bent on amassing unchecked power (the same happens in democracies with “strong western institutions”, too).

Globally, the annual average of the number of years in office for heads of governments has been on decline since the mid-1980s (see graph). Perhaps we were due for a correction, like happened in the mid-1920s. May be this time we will be lucky enough to avoid the messes that followed in the subsequent two decades (the fact that China appears to be a revisionist world power is not a great sign).

Finally, it is remarkable that even after being around for thousands of years China hasn’t figured a system of stable, regularized transfer of power that lasts for centuries. May be it is the curse of being a big country. Or may be this is just how politics works. It really does put in perspective the achievements of a number of African countries that appear to have consolidated term limits within a few decades of existence.

41 thoughts on “Xi’s power grab in China is a big deal

  1. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - News Bits

  2. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | geopost247.com

  3. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | TechParle

  4. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - LonelyBlogging.com

  5. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Thefoolishblog.com |

  6. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Peak News

  7. Pingback: Xi Units China on a Collision Course With Historical past – Pusat Informasi Terupdate

  8. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - Your True News Source

  9. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | 12 News Online

  10. Pingback: The Interpreter: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | IdubaiNews.com

  11. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | News - Zedid

  12. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Media One

  13. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Newslast24.com

  14. Pingback: The Interpreter: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - The Silk Wall

  15. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History – News Online

  16. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | C cLear World

  17. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Study course With History - Empleos de Recursos Humanos - Trabajos de Recursos Humanos - Noticias de Recursos Humanos

  18. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - World Independant Magazine

  19. Pingback: The Interpreter: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - Apsny News

  20. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - WCRCLEADERS

  21. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History » Untitled

  22. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | SilbNews

  23. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | newsheadlinesnow.xyz

  24. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - New York Store

  25. Pingback: The Interpreter: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - Europe & World News

  26. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History – BigNewsPlace

  27. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | yournews247.com

  28. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Spread What Headlines News

  29. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History – New York Times | | All Breaking News

  30. Pingback: The Interpreter: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - THE ASIA TIMES

  31. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History - New York Times | KWOTABLE

  32. Pingback: The Interpreter: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History – Planet News

  33. Pingback: The Interpreter: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History • Zenit-ka.ru

  34. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | OTCdaddy.COM |

  35. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Peace and Freedom

  36. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Your Full-Service Heavy Construction Equipment Company

  37. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Newsstand

  38. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Atlanta Reports

  39. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | Android Lover

  40. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History | technology market

  41. Pingback: Xi Sets China on a Collision Course With History – The Star News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.