africans should hold their noses and support the icc

Quoting the Economist:

These days the ICC’s biggest opponents are in Africa, which provides the court with its biggest group of members (31 out of 114) and is the scene of all the cases currently being investigated or prosecuted: in the CAR, Congo, Côte d’Ivoire, Kenya, Libya, Sudan and Uganda. Accusing the court of unfairly targeting African countries, the 53-member African Union (AU) is again calling for “African solutions to African problems”. It particularly dislikes the court’s increasing willingness to go after sitting presidents. At its summit next month it plans to extend the authority of its African Court of Justice and Human Rights to cover criminal as well as civil cases. International lawyers such as Richard Dicker of Human Rights Watch, a New York-based lobby, see this as an attempt to circumvent the ICC.

It may not work. The reason so many African cases are before the court is not because of bias; all the ICC’s cases have been referred to it either by the UN Security Council or by the countries themselves. It is because the standards of justice in Africa are often poor. Courts in many parts of the continent are packed with pliant judges keen to do their masters’ bidding. Moreover, attempts to create a regional system of African justice have so far failed. The African Court, under the AU’s aegis, has never issued a ruling of note. The AU’s pledge to ensure that Hissène Habré, held responsible for thousands of deaths as Chad’s president in the 1980s, is brought to justice has not been fulfilled. The Southern African Development Community’s tribunal, set up in 2005, has been virtually suspended since Zimbabwe refused to accept its ban on the expropriation of white farms and the 15-country regional club proved reluctant to enforce its rulings.

Many across the Continent have opposed international involvement in Africa’s affairs. Most of these Afro-nationalists have been dictators and those who depend on them, with a few true African nationalists on the fringe. My take is that Africa needs a conscience, regardless of where it comes from. As things stand tiny Botswana is the only nation that aspires to stand for justice. President Khama has condemned Mugabe, Bashir and those of their ilk.

South Africa, Nigeria, Ethiopia and the DRC, all potential continental leaders by virtue of their size, have been dismal failures at this task.

The ICC might be misguided in its attempts to decouple justice and politics. It might even bring terrible memories of the pre-sixties for those of our parents’ generation (calls of neocolonialism are all over the place). It may also be patently biased against African autocracy. But for now it is all most African peasants have against the goons that run their countries. Those who care about justice and accountability on the Continent should hold their noses and support the efforts of the court to give a voice to the voiceless.

8 thoughts on “africans should hold their noses and support the icc

  1. The ICC appears a “toothless dog” and in most instances is even turning villains into heroes; that is the “African mentality” so better to be free from the ICC if they cannot actvely and quickly persecute those charged with commiting crimes against humanity.


  2. Its obvious that Africa has sever human rights violation issues to which the ICC is the right place to answer to. However, its interesting that no one has called for the sending of the king of Bahrain or the president of Yemen to the ICC, but as soon as Libya civil war breaks out the call to send Gaddafi to the ICC comes out. I don’t disagree with the idea of the ICC or that people like Charles Taylor and Omar Bashir should be applicable to it. But its also atrocious that countries like the USA and Israel are not even members. And can you imagine China or Russia ever being brought to the ICC, not just poor powerless African states.


  3. Pingback: Judges reject kenya’s bid to stop icc case « Opalo's weblog

  4. Pingback: Making sense of the Kenyan government’s reaction to UNSC vote on ICC deferral « An Africanist Perspective

  5. Pingback: Africa’s ill-advised crusade against ‘race hunting’ tools of the West – Christian Science Monitor | Everyday News Update

  6. Pingback: Africa’s ill-advised crusade against ‘race hunting’ tools of the West – Christian Science Monitor | Perfect News Update

  7. Pingback: Africa’s ill-advised crusade against ‘race hunting’ tools of the West – Christian Science Monitor | Trending News | Latest News | Online News | Reliable News| Fast News At

  8. Pingback: Africa’s ill-advised crusade against ‘race hunting’ tools of the West – Christian Science Monitor | News Up To The Minute

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.