Two Important Lessons Americans Should Learn From the Senate Torture Report

As Americans digest the contents of the just released Senate Report on CIA’s use of torture, here are two important lessons that they ought to internalize.

  1. The release of the report neither absolves America of the deeds highlighted therein, nor does it mean that such gross violations of the rights of non-Americans have ended. As Mother Jones reported back in 2012, President Obama may have ended officially sanctioned torture, but as it continued to wage the global war on terror America merely “outsourced human rights abuse to Afghanistan, Somalia, and elsewhere” through rendition programs. In addition, CFR has calculated that over the course of 500 drone strikes under both the Bush and Obama administrations 41 men were targeted, but 1147 people were killed. Dangerous terrorists should be taken out, by all means. But at some point we must begin to ask questions about what ought to constitute an upper limit of tolerable collateral damage. Especially in relation to the lives of innocent non-combatants.
  2. By outsourcing illegal practices to governments in the developing world America is contributing to the weakening of institutions of accountability in those countries and the radicalization of potential jihadists. Six months ago I argued for caution in the ongoing militarization of US-Africa relations. My worry is that many American security arrangements with African governments are designed to bypass normal democratic channels (like direct military to military cooperation) and risk creating unaccountable militaries and governments. In Kenya, for instance, it is increasingly unclear whether the military or the elected civilian administration is in charge of national security policy (especially with regard to the mission in Somalia). Nairobi has also recently been on the spotlight accused of engaging in extra-judicial killings of suspected terrorists with foreign assistance. In addition, many governments in the region that cooperate with the US have enacted sweeping anti-terror laws, many designed to also silence domestic political dissent. If it is not yet abundantly clear, it is high time American policymakers realized that unaccountable and highly securitized governments play into the hands of jihadist recruiters.

The release of the report is certainly commendable. It is a shining example of the virtues of separation of powers, something that America, more than any other nation in history, has perfected. But it is not an end in and of itself. It ought to be a first step in acknowledging that human rights do not end at the water’s edge, and putting pressure on elected officials to devise national security and foreign relations policies that respect this fact. Despite what some Americans may say, respecting the rights of non-Americans and their desire for accountable political and military institutions will not weaken America. On the contrary it will make it stronger by bolstering its soft power, and safer.

4 thoughts on “Two Important Lessons Americans Should Learn From the Senate Torture Report

  1. Point 2 is a fantastic one – and too often ignored. It is a decidedly anti-democratic foreign policy practice that gets swept under the rug of ‘fighting terrorism’ with far less scrutiny than many other similarly dubious schemes.

    For instance, in this case, the heavy handed treatment of the CIA whistleblower is getting a lot of attention (rightly) rather than the actual geopolitical consequences of the program.

    Like

  2. That is really fascinating, You’re an overly skilled blogger.

    I’ve joined your feed and stay up for looking for extra of your excellent post.

    Also, I have shared your website in my social networks

    Like

  3. Can I simply just say what a comfort to discover an individual who actually
    understands what they are talking about over the internet.
    You certainly understand how to bring an issue to light and make it important.

    A lot more people must read this and understand this
    side of your story. I was surprised you’re not more popular because you definitely
    have the gift.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.